Article image

The Pitch-Rigging Plot That Shook Major League Baseball

Monday, 10 November 2025 00:46

Summary

Federal prosecutors in New York have unsealed a sweeping indictment against two prominent Cleveland Guardians pitchers, Emmanuel Clase and Luis Ortiz, alleging a sophisticated scheme of fraud, conspiracy, and bribery. The charges claim the players took thousands of dollars in bribes from sports bettors to intentionally manipulate the outcome and speed of specific pitches, allowing co-conspirators to win at least $450,000 on in-game proposition bets. This scandal, which stretches back to 2023, represents a profound challenge to the integrity of Major League Baseball, echoing historical crises while highlighting the new vulnerabilities introduced by the proliferation of legalised, real-time sports wagering. The case has drawn immediate comparisons to other recent federal crackdowns on corruption in professional sports, placing the issue of athlete integrity and the security of betting platforms at the centre of a national conversation.

The Unsealed Indictment

The integrity of Major League Baseball was profoundly challenged with the unsealing of a federal indictment in the Eastern District of New York on Sunday, 9 November 20251,3. The charges named two Cleveland Guardians pitchers, Emmanuel Clase and Luis Ortiz, alleging their involvement in a scheme to rig the outcomes of specific pitches during games1,2. Clase, a three-time All-Star and one of the sport’s most highly paid closers, and Ortiz, a starting pitcher, face multiple federal charges, including wire fraud conspiracy, honest services wire fraud conspiracy, conspiracy to influence sporting contests by bribery, and money laundering conspiracy3,8,10. The indictment, spanning 23 pages, details an alleged operation where the players accepted bribes to intentionally throw pitches that would allow co-conspirators to win proposition bets2,3,9. Prosecutors claim the scheme began as early as May 2023 with Clase, and Ortiz joined the operation in June 20251,3,4. The total winnings for the bettors involved in the alleged conspiracy amounted to at least $450,0001,7,9. The charges carry severe potential penalties, with each defendant facing a maximum sentence of up to 65 years in prison if convicted on all counts3,7,9. The United States Attorney for the Eastern District of New York, Joseph Nocella Jr., stated that the defendants had ‘deprived the Cleveland Guardians and Major League Baseball of their honest services,’ defrauded online betting platforms, and ‘betrayed America’s pastime’1,5. Ortiz was arrested by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) at Boston Logan International Airport on the day the indictment was unsealed, while Clase was not yet in custody1,3,8. The league had placed both players on non-disciplinary paid leave in July 2025, following an internal investigation into unusual betting activity3,8,11.

The Mechanics of the Pitch-Rigging Operation

The alleged corruption centred on the manipulation of in-game proposition bets, or ‘prop bets,’ which allow wagers on specific, granular events within a game, such as the outcome or speed of a single pitch1,2,5. The indictment outlines how the pitchers would agree in advance with their co-conspirators to throw specific types and speeds of pitches2. This insider information was then used by the bettors to place wagers on outcomes like whether a pitch would be a ball or a strike, or whether its velocity would fall above or below a certain threshold6,8,9. The scheme’s success relied on the players intentionally throwing pitches outside the strike zone, often described as ‘down in the dirt,’ to ensure a ‘ball’ outcome for the bettors3,10. Clase, a relief pitcher, allegedly began coordinating with bettors in May 2023, sometimes communicating with co-conspirators via text or phone during live Major League Baseball games, a clear violation of league rules6. The indictment cites a specific incident in April 2025 where Clase allegedly invited a bettor to a game against the Boston Red Sox and spoke with him by phone just before taking the mound8. Four minutes later, the bettor and his associates won $11,000 on a wager that Clase would throw a certain pitch slower than 97.95 mph8. In another instance in May 2025, Clase allegedly agreed to throw a ball during a game against the Los Angeles Dodgers, but the batter swung and missed, resulting in a strike2,8. This unexpected outcome cost the bettors $4,000 in wagers, leading to a tense exchange where a co-conspirator sent Clase a GIF of a man hanging himself with toilet paper, to which Clase responded with a GIF of a sad puppy dog face2,7,8. Ortiz’s alleged involvement included two specific games in June 20254. On 15 June, Ortiz was allegedly paid $5,000 to throw an intentional ball against the Seattle Mariners, with Clase receiving an additional $5,000 for facilitating the arrangement3,4,6. Two weeks later, on 27 June, Ortiz allegedly threw another fixed pitch against the St. Louis Cardinals, for which he and Clase each received $7,0004,6. Prosecutors allege that the bribes and kickbacks were sometimes funnelled through third parties and disguised, with one example being ‘repairs at the country house’ in the Dominican Republic6. The total winnings tied to Clase’s pitches were over $400,000, while wagers related to Ortiz’s manipulated pitches netted at least $60,0003,6.

The Rise of Proposition Betting and New Vulnerabilities

The case against Clase and Ortiz underscores a critical vulnerability in professional sports that has emerged with the widespread legalisation and proliferation of in-game, real-time sports betting across the United States5,16. Unlike traditional wagers on the final outcome of a game, prop bets focus on micro-events, such as the number of strikeouts a pitcher records, the speed of a pitch, or whether a specific pitch will be a ball or a strike2,5. These micro-events are far easier for a single player to manipulate without necessarily affecting the final result of the game, making the corruption harder to detect through conventional means7. The sheer volume and speed of in-game betting, which allows wagers to be placed between pitches, creates a fertile ground for this type of fraud5. The indictment highlights that the scheme was flagged not by a traditional investigation, but by sportsbooks and integrity monitors who noticed ‘unusually high in-game betting activity’ around specific pitches thrown by the two Guardians players5,8. This reliance on sophisticated monitoring systems to police the integrity of the game is a modern necessity, given the billions of pounds now wagered annually16. The alleged actions of Clase and Ortiz represent a new frontier in sports corruption, moving beyond the historical precedent of fixing entire games or seasons to the manipulation of individual, fleeting moments of play7. The fact that the players were allegedly paid relatively small sums—bribes as low as $5,000 for a single rigged pitch—despite Clase’s $20 million, five-year contract and Ortiz’s $782,600 salary, suggests a breakdown in the ethical and financial safeguards intended to protect athletes from such temptations7,8.

Echoes of Baseball’s Past

The indictment of the two Cleveland pitchers immediately recalls the most infamous betting scandals in Major League Baseball history, which have long served as cautionary tales about the fragility of public trust in the sport13,14. The most significant historical precedent remains the 1919 ‘Black Sox’ scandal, where eight members of the Chicago White Sox conspired with gamblers to intentionally lose the World Series to the Cincinnati Reds13,14,16. Despite being acquitted by a grand jury, the players, including the legendary ‘Shoeless’ Joe Jackson, were banned for life by the sport’s first commissioner, Kenesaw Mountain Landis, who declared that the integrity of the game was paramount13,14,16. The permanent ban of Pete Rose, Major League Baseball’s all-time hits leader, in 1989 for betting on baseball, including on his own team while managing the Cincinnati Reds, further cemented the league’s zero-tolerance policy12,14,15,16. The current case, however, is distinct in its focus on micro-level manipulation and its intersection with federal criminal charges5,7. The charges against Clase and Ortiz are part of a broader federal crackdown on corruption in professional sports, which has recently included the arrest of an NBA player and coach in connection with similar accusations of colluding with gambling insiders5,16. The U.S. Attorney’s statement that the players ‘betrayed America’s pastime’ is a direct invocation of the moral authority the league has historically claimed in policing its own integrity1,5,8. Major League Baseball has stated that it contacted federal law enforcement at the outset of its investigation and has fully cooperated throughout the process, indicating a unified front against the alleged corruption3,4.

Conclusion

The federal indictment of Emmanuel Clase and Luis Ortiz represents a watershed moment for Major League Baseball and the wider world of professional sports, illustrating the profound ethical and legal challenges posed by the rapid expansion of legalised sports betting5,7. The alleged scheme, which involved the manipulation of individual pitches for financial gain, demonstrates a new, insidious form of corruption that exploits the granular nature of modern prop wagering2,7. While the league’s historical response to betting scandals has been swift and severe, the current situation is complicated by the involvement of federal criminal charges, which carry the potential for decades of imprisonment3,9,14. The case will serve as a critical test of the legal system’s ability to prosecute sports integrity violations and the league’s capacity to safeguard its product in an era of ubiquitous, real-time wagering5,16. The outcome of the proceedings against the two pitchers will not only determine their careers but will also set a powerful precedent for how professional sports leagues and law enforcement agencies manage the inherent risks of a multi-billion-pound betting industry7,11. The immediate and long-term consequences for the Cleveland Guardians, the players, and the public trust in the fairness of the game remain significant and uncertain1,4,8.

References

  1. MLB Players Luis Ortiz and Emmanuel Clase Indicted for Allegedly Rigging Bets Based on Pitches

    Supports details on the indictment, the charges (fraud, bribery), the amount won by gamblers ($450,000), the timeline (Clase starting May 2023, Ortiz June 2025), the potential prison sentence, and the US Attorney's statement.

  2. Two Cleveland Guardians pitchers charged with betting on pitches: 'They betrayed America's pastime'

    Provides specific details on the pitch-rigging method (intentionally throwing balls/strikes), the amount won from Clase's pitches ($400,000), the specific incident with the Dodgers game and the GIF exchange, and the nature of proposition bets.

  3. Emmanuel Clase, Luis Ortiz Indicted On Gambling Charges

    Confirms the specific federal charges (wire fraud conspiracy, honest services wire fraud conspiracy, conspiracy to influence sporting contests by bribery, and money laundering conspiracy), the maximum sentence (65 years), the specific bribe details for the June 15 incident ($5K each), and MLB's cooperation.

  4. Guardians' Emmanuel Clase, Luis Ortiz Indicted on Charges Related to Pitch Betting Scheme

    Details the specific bribe amounts and dates for Ortiz's alleged fixed pitches (June 15 and June 27, 2025, for $5,000 and $7,000 respectively) and confirms the Guardians lost both games.

  5. MLB pitchers Emmanuel Clase and Luis Ortiz charged with taking bribes to rig pitches for bettors

    Provides the full names of the indicted players (Emmanuel Clase de la Cruz and Luis Leandro Ortiz Ribera), the US Attorney's quote about 'betrayed America's pastime,' the role of prop bets, and the fact that the scandal was flagged by integrity monitors.

  6. Cleveland Guardians Pitchers Charged in MLB Betting Scand...

    Offers specific details on the pitch types (slower sliders or intentional balls), the communication method (texting/calling co-conspirators during games), the New York Mets game example ($27,000 won), the disguise of bribes ('repairs at the country house'), and the $60,000 winnings tied to Ortiz.

  7. Emmanuel Clase, Luis Ortiz Indicted on Illegal Gambling Charges

    Confirms the total winnings ($450,000), the small bribe amounts ($5,000), Clase's contract ($20 million), Ortiz's salary ($782,600), and the pressure from bettors (GIF exchange).

  8. MLB pitchers Emmanuel Clase and Luis Ortiz charged with taking bribes to rig pitches for bettors

    Confirms the players' native country (Dominican Republic), the specific Red Sox game example ($11,000 won on pitch speed), the Dodgers game incident, and the players' status on non-disciplinary paid leave since July.

  9. Everything we know about Emmanuel Clase, Luis Ortiz indictment in MLB betting scandal

    Confirms the total winnings ($450,000), the maximum sentence (65 years), and the 23-page length of the indictment.

  10. MLB pitchers Emmanuel Clase and Luis Ortiz charged with taking bribes to rig pitches for bettors

    Confirms the specific charges and the method of throwing pitches 'down in the dirt, well out of the strike zone.'

  11. Cleveland Guardians betting scandal updates: Luis Ortiz and Emmanuel Clase indicted

    Confirms the dates the players were placed on leave (Ortiz July 3, Clase July 28) and the general nature of the indictment.

  12. A brief history of MLB gambling scandals

    Provides historical context, specifically mentioning Pete Rose's permanent ban in 1989 for betting on baseball.

  13. Gambling in baseball: Scandals through the years

    Provides historical context, specifically mentioning the 1919 'Black Sox' scandal and the lifetime bans.

  14. 7 of Baseball's Biggest Scandals

    Provides historical context, confirming the 'Black Sox' scandal, the role of Commissioner Landis, and the Pete Rose ban.

  15. Baseball's 10 Biggest Scandals

    Provides historical context, confirming Pete Rose's betting on the Reds from 1985-87 and the Black Sox details.

  16. 12 biggest gambling scandals in sports history, from Pete Rose MLB ban to Operation Nothing but Bet

    Provides historical context (Black Sox, Pete Rose) and connects the current case to the broader federal crackdown, mentioning the recent NBA player and coach arrests.